A couple years ago I crunched some stats and came up with a list of 114 of the greatest MLB players of all time, one selected for each year since 1895. Since then, I’ve added Albert Pujols (2009) and John Smoltz (2010) to the list.
For 2011, I’ll be choosing from a short list of 6 players who have already accomplished enough to all but ensure a spot for themselves in the National Baseball Hall of Fame. Which one of these players deserves the next spot in my exclusive list of greatest MLB players of all time?
Curt Schilling

216-146 W-L, 3.46 ERA, 3,116 SO, 22SV
6x All-Star
He’s a member of the 3,000 Strikeout club, and to-date every single pitcher to reach that milestone has gone to the Hall of Fame after becoming eligible.
Mariano Rivera

75-56 W-L, 2.22 ERA, 1,074 SO, 578 SV
11x All-Star
Mo needs only 24 more saves to break Trevor Hoffman’s all-time saves record. If he becomes the all-time saves leader, he’ll keep that distinction for a long time since the active player with the next most saves just broke 300 (that’ll be K-Rod).
Ichiro Suzuki

.328 BA, 90 HR, 579 RBI, 402 SB
10x All-Star
What if Sadaharu Oh came to the United States in 1967 to play in the Major Leagues and hit over 600 homers? That’s pretty much what Ichiro is doing today. He won’t break Pete Rose’s all-time hits record, but he might well get 3,000 MLB hits and more hits overall than Pete Rose over the course of his career.
Derek Jeter

.312 BA, 236 HR, 1,155 RBI, 330 SB
11x All-Star
Say all you want about how overrated Yankees players are, but with only 6 hits to go to reach 3,000 career hits, Jeter is a sure bet for the baseball Hall of Fame.
Vladimir Guerrero

.318 BA, 442 HR, 1,461 RBI, 179 SB
9x All-Star
If Vladimir Guerrero can stay healthy and productive for about 3 more seasons, he has a good chance of reaching 500 homers and 3,000 hits.
Roy Halladay

178-89 W-L, 3.29 ERA, 1,829 SO, 1SV
7x All-Star
As the youngest player in this list (34), Halladay probably has a few more years of dominant stuff left in his arm. He has already won two Cy Young Awards, pitched a perfect game, and leads all active pitchers in complete-game shutouts (19). The scary thing is, 2011 is shaping up to be the best season of his career.